שאל את הרב שאל את הרב
  • Mourning
  • Brachot
  • Kosher Kitchen
  • Festivals
  • Family Purity
  • Maaser Kesofin
  • Sefer Torah, Tefillin and Mezuot
  • Tzitzit and Tefillin
  • Tefilla
  • Medicine
  • Shabbat
  • Miscellaneous
  • Life Events
  • Fasts
  • Yichud
  • Mourning
  • Brachot
  • Kosher Kitchen
  • Festivals
  • Family Purity
  • Maaser Kesofin
  • Sefer Torah, Tefillin and Mezuot
  • Tzitzit and Tefillin
  • Tefilla
  • Medicine
  • Shabbat
  • Miscellaneous
  • Life Events
  • Fasts
  • Yichud
Theme by Pojo.me - WordPress Themes
Design by Elementor
Yichud: Tinted Windows
  • Hebrew
  • English
  • French
  • Portuguese (Brazil)
  • Russian
  • Spanish
29 בOctober 2019 13:52 No Comments ניהול אתר

Yichud: Tinted Windows

Q) Regarding yichud: If a man is driving a car with a female passenger in the car, and the car has tinted windows – is this an issur of yichud?)

A) We first need to clarify if being alone with a lady in a car is included in the prohibition of yichud

Rav Shlomo Zalman Aurbach[1] discusses the possibility of a car being subject to yichud and presents the argument that a car is not subject to yichud – because the occupants of the car are visible to passers-by and other users of the road. Therefore, a car will usually be classified as pesach posu’ach lirshus harabim – (lit. there is an open entrance to a public thoroughfare) and subsequently there is no problem of yichud[2].

 

Rav Shlomo Zalman continues to explain that even though the car can, at any given moment, divert onto a deserted side street (which is subject to the issur of yichud) and it could be argued that yichud should be prohibited in a car at all times because of this possibility; in fact yichud is mutor in a car – when the car is located in a populated area, and we are not concerned with the possibility of the car relocating to a more deserted area. This is because the issur of yichud depends on the current situation, as it is now, and the fact that a situation can develop into a prohibition of yichud at a later stage is irrelevant now[3].

 

Rav Moshe Feinstein[4] opines that certainly l’chatchilo one should not allow yichud in a car – because of the possibility that the car can easily be driven to a deserted area in which there will be a prohibition of yichud.

However, continues Rav Moshe Feinstein, in extenuating circumstances one can be lenient, because according to the letter of the law we do not have to be concerned with the possibility that the car can relocate to a deserted area; and we only need to be concerned with the current location of the car (the same argument as Rav Shlomo Zalman).

 

The sefer Mishnas Hayichud[5] (Rav Moshe Paniri) points out that the aforementioned leniencies will only be applicable to a car that has regular (non-tinted) windows. If the car windows are tinted and therefore the occupants of the car are not visible to passers-by then there will be a prohibition of yichud.

 

However, if it is possible to see the driver through a regular window (as is usually the case that the windscreen is made of regular clear glass), there will be no problem of yichud, even though one can’t see the other passenger(s). This is because the driver is not subject to yichud if he is in view, and additionally, once the driver is not subject to yichud he can act as a shomer and allow the “seclusion” of another man and woman in the back of the car – as long as he (the driver) can see them.

 

[1] מנחת שלמה (ח”א צ”א כ”א)

[2] ע’ שו”ע אבה”ע ס’ כ”ב סע’ ט’

[3] וראיה לזה – פתח פתוח לרה”ר עצמו, שבכל עת ובכל זמן יכול לנעול הדלת ואז יהא מצב של ייחוד; ולמרות האפשרות הזאת מותר להתייחד כשיש פתח פתוח לרה”ר ולא חוששין לשמא ינעלו הדלת

[4] שו”ת אג”מ אבה”ע ח”ד תשובה ס”ה ג’

[5] על סע’ ט’

.

Car Tinted windows Yichud in Car
« Previous
Next »
Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

בשעה טובה בימים אלו יוצאים לאור ספר של שו”ת דרכי הלכה בעברית וספר נוסף בספרדית , מתוך שו”ת שנשאלו במרכז העולמי למענה הלכתי.

רבני קהילות המעונינים בספר ללא תשלום ניתן להזמין

בדרכים הבאות:

מייל – ‏‪as*@***av.org‬‏
ווצאפ – 0543198126

הספר מחולק חינם לקהילות ישראל בארץ ובעולם

Search
Ask a Question

For your information, identifying details of those who submit questions through our website and Beit Hora’ah are treated with confidentiality and are not transmitted to any third party.

חיפוש לפי חודשים ושנים
  • September 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • May 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • March 2019
חיפוש לפי נושאים
2020 Aveilus Birkas Kohanim Bosor B'cholov Brachos Brachot Brochos candles Challah Chanukah Chol Hamoed chometz Elul Fast Festivals guest Kosher Kitchen Ma'acholos Asuros Mayim Acharonim Ma’ariv Meat Mikva'os Milk Misc Niddah Niddoh pas habo’oh b’kisnin Pesach pidyon haben Preparing Salad on Shabbos Psik Reishe Purim ribis Rosh Hashana Shabbat Shabbos Shemitta Shemittah Taking challah Taking challah on Shabbos Tefilla Tefillo Tevilas Keilim the Three Weeks Veses
Scroll to top